Will whenever dates are provided, he is given with twenty four hours of few days you to definitely really does maybe not match with that go out because during the actual records. One example occurs in Harry Potter together with Prisoner regarding Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney identifies sixteen October due to the fact Saturday, even when 16 October 1993 is a monday.
There are also contradictions inside the courses of this type. Like, within the Harry Potter plus the Goblet out of Flame, both 1 September and 2 Sep are offered as the Mondays and you may, when you look at the Harry Potter additionally the Prisoner out of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is determined on 20 April, but careful parsing of the text implies that it might possess occurred no after than simply March.
Including, during the Harry Potter therefore the Cup out-of Flames people say that the Champions was in fact selected toward Saturday 30 October, however, 30 October are a monday into the 1994.
When you look at the chapter 7 from Quidditch From Many years, they do say the first Quidditch Community Glass was held inside the 1473. Should your championship try held all of the number of years, it conflicts on declaration from inside the Cup off Flame your 1994 Business Cup is brand new 422nd. In the event the Quidditch From Age excellent, this new 422nd Quidditch Community Glass manage in reality fall-in the year 3161, however, if Cup away from Flame is good, the original Industry Mug was actually stored inside 306.
Historic trouble [ ]
Whilst the show, with regards to the timeline produced by the new Chamber away from Gifts reference, is determined about 1990s, the fresh new series will appears as if it’s devote the new later nineties so you’re able to mid-2000s, about concurrent on the guide of one’s instructions. Inside Harry Potter plus the 1 / 2 of-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a masculine pronoun to mention towards the « predecessor » of the Primary Minister of your own United kingdom. Depending on the a lot more than schedule, this will take place in the summer months out-of 1996, if Prime Minister is John Big, whoever quick predecessor is a woman (‘s the reason first interviewing Fudge, the ebook mentions the newest election, however, Significant wasn’t very first decided to go with and only took more than immediately after Thatcher resigned.
It’s possible, yet not unlikely, that Fudge will be speaing frankly about a far more faraway predecessor, due to the fact Thatcher got workplace prior to Fudge allegedly became Minister to have Magic. (Though one can possibly imagine a situation where Fudge are delegated of the Minister to possess Magic in order to meet to the Primary Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in an inferior workplace.) On top of that, the newest identification and you will reputation for the top Minister portrayed appears to far more directly match that Tony Blair than of John Major. A blog post in the Each and every day Post notes one Rowling are close toward upcoming-Chancellor of one’s Exchequer Gordon Brown (have a tendency to viewed as a competitor so you’re able to Blair’s leaders of your Labour Party, which been successful your and you may turned into Perfect Minister), and therefore she has been wanting to let you know Blair’s poor top. In the event the guides was place in connect having guide day out of Philosopher’s Brick, up coming so it event would take place in 2002 (just after Blair became Best Minister).
Although not, it absolutely was after reported that twenty-two November is a saturday, which it was at 1994
The same disease pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who had been stated to be 665 in the course of the newest very first guide, but Nicolas Flamel was a bona fide historical contour and you will would not have reached you to definitely ages until 1996, around the go out the initial book is blogged. This new rebuttal for this is the fact that the day the « real » Nicolas Flamel was given birth to doesn’t talk to the fresh Nicolas Flamel out of Harry Potter.
A different sort of condition is present out of Rubeus Hagrid’s period since the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s implied throughout the series you to definitely Hagrid was given one updates inside many years of their expulsion regarding school inside 1942. In one to world from Harry Potter in addition to Cup off Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces in the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper frequently convergence with Molly’s many years at school, it looks impractical one she remembers a previous gamekeeper. But not, you’ll be able you to definitely Hagrid don’t become an effective gamekeeper instantaneously immediately following getting expelled, but alternatively already been https://brightwomen.net/tr/sicak-vietnamli-kadinlar/ because Ogg’s secretary. This is exactly possible as the whenever Harry thinks which he commonly getting expelled having flying towards broomstick instead of consent in the first year, the guy secret when the however be permitted to remain on since Hagrid’s assistant.
